« June 2007 | Main

July 23, 2007

You Just Lost, What's Next?

You Just Lost, What’s Next?
 
        You just lost your case. You feel that an appeal is in order. What is a person to do? Well, the first thing that needs to be done is that you have to file a notice of appeal. In most jurisdictions, if not all, a notice of appeal initiates the appellate process. You also should know that you’re in a time crunch. That is, most courts require that a notice of appeal be filed within 30 days of your final judgment or order.
          The filing of a notice of appeal isn’t a hard thing to do, but initiating an appeal often becomes a stressful, bewildering experience for many litigants. Why? Well there are several reasons. First, most trial attorneys have no interest in pursuing an appeal- that is perfectly fine. However, many trial attorneys fail to notify their client of their appellate rights until a few days remain to file a notice of appeal, and quite frankly, that is not right. Trial attorneys should notify their clients of their appellate rights immediately, and also offer to file a notice of appeal on their client’s behalf.
          The second problem that clients run into is that they contact an appellate attorney with little or almost no time to review the potential appeal. That is, with a few days remaining to file the notice of appeal. Many appellate attorneys will not take on an appeal under such time constraining circumstances. Indeed, one should never hire an appeals attorney who immediately agrees to take on an appeal or takes on an appeal with little or no analysis of the case. Any decent appellate attorney will want to review the case before agreeing to take on an appeal.
          The third problem that clients run into is themselves. After losing an appeal, people generally bemoan their fate and do the worst thing possible- they do nothing! People who do nothing get nothing. If you want a chance to overturn an unfair verdict or judgment, then you need actively pursue your appeal.
          Ok, so you just lost, what should you do? I would suggest that you file your notice of appeal on your own. Simply go down to the clerk’s office, and generally speaking, most clerks will guide you through on how to file a notice of appeal. This allows you to preserve your appellate rights, and gives you the time to select an appellate attorney in a deliberate, purposeful manner. If you are unable to find an appellate attorney, then you always have the right to withdraw your appeal. However, its far better to keep appellate fate in your own hands and that is why the filing of a notice of appeal is so important. So in essence, file your notice of appeal, and then start looking for an appellate attorney.
Written by John V. Siskopoulos, Esq. Mr. Siskopoulos handles civil and criminal appeals, and may be reached at 800-971-5515 or at jvs@maappeals.com  Copyright by John V. Siskopoulos, P.C.

July 02, 2007

Analyzing an Appeal: From the Client's Perspective

Analyzing an Appeal: From the Client’s Perspective
 
        An attorney, particularly an appellate practitioner, is the best person to analyze the merits of an appeal. However, the pursuit of most appeals are often, if not most times, decided by the client. That often places a client in a difficult position. That is, how does a client know if he or she has a meritorious, winnable appeal? This is a difficult question to answer, but it is one that can be answered. In order for a client to understand and decide whether they have a legitimate appeal, they should resolve the following questions:
 
1)      Judicial Error- This term is a legal term, but in layman’s terms it should be applied in the following way: Did the judge fail to understand an important issue? If you answer this question with a yes, you may have an appealable issue. The problem is how can a person, not trained in the law, comprehend if a judge failed to understand an important issue in your case? Well, simply ask yourself was the judge’s decision fair or reasonable? If it strikes you as unfair or unjustified, you may have a legitimate appeal on your hands.
2)      Attorney Failings- Most appeals are often analyzed whether the court created a prejudicial error that may be the basis for an appeal. But, many appeals should come under a far different analysis. That is, did your attorney fail to persuasively argue a critical issue in your case? If you answer this with a yes, once again, you may have a strong case for an appeal. Why? Many attorneys address the appropriate arguments in the lower courts, but simply addressing the issue is often not enough. They must vigorously and passionately argue on behalf of your case. If they did not, perhaps you should seek a second chance on an appeal.
 
If you believe judicial error or your attorney failing you occurred in the lower courts, perhaps you should consider the pursuit of an appeal to the higher courts. The higher courts may render a far different verdict. However, you should answer one final question before considering an appeal, that is: Do you have the will for an appeal? In short, can you deal with the costs, time and personal drive that is required for any successful appeal? If you can, then perhaps you should be preparing for your appeal. If you cannot, simply lick your wounds, and move on. A successful appeal, even more so than legal skill or strategy, requires strong determination. You must have a forceful, determined spirit to be successful on an appeal.
 
Written by John V. Siskopoulos, Esq. Mr. Siskopoulos handles civil and criminal appeals, and may be reached at 800-971-5515 or at jvs@maappeals.com  Copyright by John V. Siskopoulos, P.C.

Hosting by Yahoo!